Since 1844
A short history of Portersville
The area that would become Portersville was originally settled in the early 19th century as part of Muddy Creek Township in Butler County, Pennsylvania.
The first recorded village name was Stewartsville, likely named after the first settler, Robert S. Stewart, who arrived in 1796. His son, Robert Stewart, was born in the village on September 15, 1808. Robert Stewart would later lay out the land in 1828, when several settlers constituted the borough, including Thomas Christy, James Stewart, John Stewart, Thomas Brandon, Dr. Cowden, James Cowden, and Robert Craig with their families.
The first post office was established between 1826-1828. The first postmaster, John Stewart, held the position for ten years, when he was succeeded by Robert Craig. The post office was moved to a building opposite of Brenneman Hotel in 1838.
During the establishment of the post office, it is believed that Stewartsville was renamed to Portersville, in honor of the 9th Governor of Pennsylvania, David R. Porter. However, Porter was not sworn into office until January 1839, and he is the only namesake to serve as Governor of Pennsylvania. It is more plausible that the borough was renamed after the post office moved in 1838, when Porter would have been elected and incumbent as Governor.
The first merchant in the borough was Robert Craig, who established a general store in 1829. By 1882, there were six stores in operation throughout the borough, including two grocery stores, two dry goods stores, one millinery, and one drug store.
In 1845, Portersville Village was incorporated as a borough, and the first election was held in a small frame building called the Town Hall. The first Justices of the Peace were James Hall and Robert Stewart, who refused to accept his commission, but Mr. Hall served in the capacity for several terms in succession. The first constable was William Sharp, who continued to be elected for several terms.
Adapted (trimmed) from the Wikipedia article Portersville, Pennsylvania, revision 1378796898 by its contributors, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.